My daughter loves to read. She's eight years old and has really started to be able to plough through a good novel in a reasonable amount of time. Having finished the Harry Potter series last year and going through a variety of shorter youth books since, I noticed the Lightning Thief book at Chapters and let her have a look at the first chapter before deciding she liked it.
I have a basic theory that any book that gets turned into a movie is probably interesting enough in story to be readable. Having seen the trailers but not the movie, I bought her the book and hoped she'd enjoy it. After finishing it and begging for the next books, she let my wife borrow it and then me. Turns out, aside from some very silly plot elements making it very clear this is not a thought provoking book for adults, its a pretty fun story. Saturday morning cartoon fun, not Lord of the Rings.
Purchasing and borrowing our way through the next three books, my daughter wanted to see the movie. After giving my usual warnings that movies are never as good as the books on which they're based, we rented it just the other night. I must say, my warning wasn't stern enough even for myself. Had it not been for my daughter wanting to finish the movie, I might've returned it to the movie store as defective -- in content.
I'm not just saying its a rendition of the story, since that's pretty common with such book-turned-movie attempts, its also a pretty bad movie. We're not talking plot compression, but something more akin to stealing character names and places and then writing a whole new story set in a similar universe. I would go well over my word count if I were to list the things I disliked in the movie, so I won't bother.
With the movie now firmly brushed aside, we're all looking forward to reading The Last Olympian, but also sad another good series comes to an end and we must again do the hunt for good reading material for a young reader who enjoys books.

Stumble It!

